Katie tells Simon that he failed her little test. Simon explains himself and insists that they will never make it if they loose faith in each other. Katie assures him that she loves him and they make love. Later, Margo learns that traces of Dahlia's blood were found in her car. Luke runs home and tells Lily that he wants Aaron to stay. Lily shares the news that she's expecting with her son and Emma, but Luke remains disappointed that Aaron is leaving. Seeing how important it is to her son, Lily decides to talk Aaron into staying. Meanwhile, Holden tries to get Aaron to open up to him, but Aaron remains distant and insists on leaving. Lily arrives and asks him to hang around. Aaron eventually relents and agrees to stay at Emma's. Hal tells Barbara in no uncertain terms that Emily belongs in his house, not her. He makes it clear that they have no future together and he sets some ground rules for her to visit with Will. At the police station, James reiterates his offer to trade Carly and Emily for Barbara. Craig grabs the phone and ruins Jack's chance to trace the call. Paul arrives and overhears them arguing about whether or not to offer Barbara up as bait for James. Craig is persuasive and finally gets Paul to agree to talk to Barbara about doing something to help end Stenbeck's reign of terror. Jack is determined to make a plan where no one, not even Barbara, will get hurt. Craig goes to see Barbara and asks her to turn herself over to James. When Barbara refuses, Craig points out how selfish she is being.

Jake calls Dr. Michaels to find out if there is another route they can take with Abigail to help her regain her memory. Dr. Michaels says that she will check into it and get back to him. The trial begins and Tom calls Mary to the witness stand. Mary is reminded by the judge that she is still under oath. She nods her head in agreement. Tom starts to question her about her relationship with Nick. The DA objects and says that all this is on the record. The judge asks Tom where he is going with this line of questioning. He tells the judge that it will be pertinent to the line of questioning. The judge tells him to continue. Tom asks Mary who had bought the airline tickets. Did she purchase them or did Nick. Mary replies that she doesn't know. Tom asks if she bought them. Mary says that she did not. Tom says that Nick must have purchased them. Mary looks uncomfortable. Tom walks over to his briefcase and picks up an envelope that usually holds airline tickets. He looks inside the envelope and says that they were going first class. Tom looks at Mary and asks how she felt when she found out that Nick had cancelled her ticket and wasn't taking her anywhere. Tom goes on questioning Mary and finally Mary gets upset and says that it was not about the tickets. Tom asks her what it was about. Mary points at Abigail and says, "It was about her. She killed him! I saw her kill Nick with the music box!" The judge tells her to control herself and Tom says that he has no further questions. The judge says that the court is in recess until tomorrow. Tom walks over to Abigail and Molly and Jake join them. They tell Tom that he was terrific. Jake says that he thinks that Tom established a reasonable doubt. Dr. Michaels walks in and Molly tells Jake that she is there. Jake walks out with her. Abigail asks Molly why Dr. Michaels is there. Molly explains that Jake is trying to find a way for her to regain her memory. Tom and Molly and Abigail walk out and join Dr. Michaels and Jake. Dr. Michaels explains that there is a new procedure where Abigail will be fully awake, but her brain would think that she is asleep. Abigail is excited and wants to try the new procedure. Abigail asks Tom about the tickets that he used in the courtroom. He puts the tickets in his pocket and says that he is going to Cleveland next week. The all laugh and Tom says that he will have to put Abigail on the stand. Molly says no, but Abigail says that it is ok. Tom says that the jury needs to hear from Abigail that she is innocent. Abigail tells Dr. Michaels that she needs to remember what happened that night and fast. She says that she needs to schedule an appointment.

Simon and Katie are working around their cottage. Katie starts to clean up and finds a watch on the floor. She remembers seeing Dahlia wearing the watch the night of her celebration at Java Underground. Simon walks up behind Katie and asks what is she doing. Katie turns around and hides the watch from Simon. Katie starts to ramble and Simon stops her and asks if everything is ok. He tells her that she is rambling and can hardly breathe. She blames it on the dust and says that she probably just needs a mask. The phone rings and Simon answers it. Margo is calling to tell Simon that Dahlia's case could possibly be considered a homicide and she needs to question him again. Simon hides this from Katie and tells Margo that he will meet her at Java. When he hangs up, Simon makes an excuse to Katie and leaves. Katie talks to herself and says that she will trust her husband. She waits a few seconds and then heads out the door to follow Simon.

Craig shows up at the police station and tries to convince Margo that he is needed in the search for Carly and Emily. He tells Margo that he visited Barbara and tried to convince her to go for Stenbeck's offer. Margo says that she will add harassment to his list of charges. Craig ignores her and asks where he can find Jack. Margo tells him that she is going to meet Simon at Java and suggests that he come with her. Craig says that he will stay behind and hold down the fort and wait for Jack. Margo gives him a choice. He can either be locked up in a cell or come with her to Java. He decides that going to Java with her will be a good experience and they head out the door.

At Java, Craig takes a table away from Margo and Simon. Margo explains to Simon that some blood had been found under the floor mat of Dahlia's car and the blood type matched the blood type on Dahlia's blood donor card. Margo tells him that she needs an official statement. Simon tells her that he will give her whatever she needs. He tells Margo about the keys that Katie had found. Simon confides in Margo that Dahlia is a psychopath that is harboring ill feelings toward him and will do anything to destroy his life. Dahlia's lawyer hears Simon and walks over to him and tells them that Dahlia is not a psychopath. She states that Dahlia only loved her sister and he couldn't stand it so he killed her. Craig is watching all this drama from his table and then he sees Katie looking in the window at him. She motions him to come outside. Craig mutters, "Why are all the women in this family so high maintenance." He gets up and goes outside. Katie starts telling him about Simon and Dahlia and finding Dahlia's car keys and her watch. Craig asks if she thinks Simon killed her. Katie shushes him and says that she totally trusts her husband. Craig suggests that she hire a private detective. As Craig is talking, Katie realizes that if Dahlia were stealing her money, she would want to create a diversion like setting up Simon for a murder. Katie takes off. Craig walks back inside and yells over to Margo, "Rain check on that jail thing, I have lives to save!" Craig runs out and Margo lets out a huge sigh and rolls her eyes.

Katie goes back to the cottage and an express mail package arrives. When she opens the package she finds a check for a very large amount of money. She looks at the check, dumbfounded. She says, "Well, there goes the cheating theory."

Paul shows up at Lily's house and asks Rose to marry him. After trying to talk him out of it, she gives in and accepts.

Jack shows up at Hal's house and talks with Barbara about James' offer. Barbara says that she will help. Jack tells her that they will have an undercover officer go to meet James instead of Barbara. Barbara says that James will see that coming a mile away. Jack convinces her to take the phone call from James, but the undercover officer will go in her place. Barbara reluctantly agrees. Jack tells Barbara that he will wait for her in his car and will drive her to the police station. After Jack is gone, Barbara takes some of Hal's sleeping pills and puts them in her pocket and walks out the door. They go to the police station and before James' call comes through, Jack informs her to keep him on the line as long as possible. Barbara takes the call from James and they banter back and forth and finally James tells her to meet him at the old mill in one hour and he hangs up the phone. Barbara tries to keep him on the line, but it is too late. She apologizes to Jack for not keeping him on the line long enough. The undercover policewoman comes in and she looks a lot like Barbara. Barbara gives her some clothes that she can wear so she will look like Barbara. The policewoman heads to the interrogation room to change clothes. She tells Jack that she could use a hot cup of tea. Jack tells her that it will be waiting for her in the car. After Jack walks away, Barbara prepares a cup of tea and adds the powder from the sleeping pill she stole from Hal. She takes the tea in to the policewoman. Later, Jack comes back and knocks on the interrogation room and tells the policewoman that it is time to go. The woman walks out all shrouded in black. Jack asks if she is armed. The woman pulls back her cloak and reveals her gun. Jack says they need to go and walks over to the door. The woman turns and looks back into the interrogation room and the policewoman is passed out on the floor. Barbara turns and follows Jack out of the squad room.