Ivy sadly explains to Sam how her life seems to have completely unraveled in recent months. Sheridan can't resist trying on her wedding band but her action rattles a superstitious Theresa. Ethan learns that the tabloid now knows the identity of the person who sent them the anonymous e-mail. Staring at David, Grace has a frightening vision of losing her entire family. Sheridan agrees to take off the ring to humor Theresa but she suddenly gets dizzy and collapses. Eager to help his pal, Chad volunteers to break into the tabloid office and find the name of the person who ruined Ethan's life. Meanwhile, Gwen is pleased when Mort promises to run his story just in time to spoil Theresa's wedding day. After Eve brings her around, Sheridan assures everyone she was just weakened by lack of food. Tabitha sneaks a peek at Sheridan's ring, however, and is amused to realize that it's been coated with poison. Grace tells Sam about her scary encounter with a stranger. Luis and Ethan are taken aback to hear that male strippers are expected at the bridal shower. Later, the prospective grooms waylay the strippers and don their Zorro costumes to surprise their brides. David sneaks into Grace's room and watches her sleep.

The wind chimes continue to indicate Tabitha is doomed. A frantic Tabitha learns she can't do anything to prevent her downfall. She and Timmy head for Hecuba's underground lair to consult the "Face in the Pool."

David stands ominously over Grace as she sleeps. Grace tosses and turns as she dreams someone is in her room. Sam enters and is startled to find his wife so agitated. Grace fills Sam in on her terrifying dream, and Sam assures her it wasn't real. After they leave the room, David comes out of hiding...

Posing as the male strippers, a masked Luis and Ethan are surprised when Sheridan and Theresa throw themselves at them. The grooms-to-be are appalled by their fiancées' wild behavior. As the women cheer them on, Sheridan kisses Luis while Theresa locks lips with Ethan. A furious Luis and Ethan reveal their identities, much to Sheridan and Theresa's "shock." The girls then burst into laughter, informing Luis and Ethan they knew it was them all along. Hank and Chad had called ahead and told the girls about the guys' plan to switch places with the strippers.

Hank and Miguel warn Chad not to break into the tabloid office, but Chad is determined to discover who betrayed Ethan. When the guys arrive at the bridal shower, Whitney overhears Hank and Miguel worrying about Chad. Later, Chad leaves for the tabloid office. Meanwhile, the reporter and his editor celebrate their scoop and anticipate their paper hitting the stands the next day - the day of Ethan and Theresa's wedding.