At Club Elixir, Jamal continues to worry about the newspaper clipping about the mysterious death of a professor in Wyoming and looks over the data he has collected so far. At the same time, Imani receives a phone call from her grandmother and Jamal overhears the conversation. Imani's grandmother reports that someone has been asking questions about Imani and Imani again instructs Medea NOT to talk to anyone! As Imani walks past Jamal, Jamal drops a copy of the clipping about the mysterious death of the professor in Wyoming. When Imani sees the clipping, she immediately accuses Jamal of taking the clipping from Imani's secret box. However, Jamal insists that this is a different copy of the same article because Jamal has been doing some of his own research. Jamal then admits that he overheard Imani speaking to her grandmother, even though Imani told Jamal that her grandmother was dead! Imani declares that she has a good reason for NOT letting Jamal in on details of her life, but Jamal implores Imani again to let Jamal help her and that Imani's trouble is serious if she is being accused of murder! However, Jamal reminds Imani that Jamal NEEDS some answers in order to help Imani. Imani finally confesses that she KNEW the professor who was murdered and that he had been Imani's English professor. When Jamal asks if Imani was in love with the professor, Imani insists that the professor was just a friend who had been very nice to Imani. Imani insists that she knows NOTHING about the professor's murder ~ but, by asking questions about Imani, Jamal MAY have made it possible for someone to track Imani down and kill her. At the same time, in an unknown place, a man with a gun looks at a file that includes Imani's photograph!

Later, with the Morley Family Heirloom Power Ring in her hand, Livvie stops off at Club Elixir to order a romantic, gourmet dinner for two to take out. Jack announces that Livvie acts like she is "up to something" and Livvie retorts that Jack is obviously STILL jealous of Livvie's relationship with Caleb. After Jack and Livvie trade barbed insults, Jack rushes off to call in the take out order. While sitting alone, Livvie observes that she and Jack were once able to be friends, even though they were estranged. When Jack returns, Livvie tries to offer an olive branch to Jack, but Jack curtly refuses to speak with Livvie about their mutual past. As Livvie leaves Club Elixir with her dinner, Livvie takes out the ring and wishes that Jack could quit hating her so much. Later, Jack buys one red rose from a flower vendor and told the bartender that Jack is taking the rest of the night off and asks Jeff to lock up.

In Hades, Rafe challenges the Mystery Voice to meet Rafe face to face and reminds The Voice that, since Alison has NOT shown up in Hades, Alison is STILL safe. But, the Voice reminds Rafe that Rafe is STILL stuck in Hades! Rafe argues that he only sought to end the curse of the ring, but the Mystery Voice informs Rafe that ONLY those who should have NEVER wished on the ring are truly cursed. In the hands of its rightful owner, the ring is a dutiful servant. Rafe comments that The Voice speaks of the ring as if the ring had a will of its own. When Rafe protest that he can NOT change the past but CAN change the future, the Mystery Voice informs Rafe that Rafe already HAS changed the future! By taking a trip in to Hades, Rafe violated a sacred code and making the decision to visit Hades WAS the defining moment of Rafe's life. The Mystery Voice ominously declares that Rafe's fate IS sealed. The Mystery Voice went on to inform Rafe that, even IF Rafe COULD get the ring back now, it would NOT MATTER! But Rafe declares that Rafe believes that NOTHING is EVER sealed! The Mystery Voice informs Rafe that Rafe WAS the one who set the wheels in motion for the NEXT impending tragedy and RAFE is the one who will have to live with the consequences of Rafe's decision for all eternity. Rafe insists that he has overcome serious consequences before and will do it again. When the Mystery Voice reminds Rafe that he has left Alison unprotected to make his descent into Hades, Rafe argues that Alison is too smart to fall for any evil trick that Caleb and his cohorts might play ~ and that Rafe is convinced that the love between Rafe and Alison WILL endure! But, the Mystery Voice informs Rafe that Rafe WILL live to regret his journey into the Netherworld. When Rafe suddenly realizes that he might NEVER see Alison again, Rafe remembers that he was sent back to earth to BE with Alison ~ NOT to defeat Caleb. Rafe suddenly realizes that all of Rafe's attempts to defeat Caleb have been a distraction away from Rafe's TRUE mission ~ which was to BE with Alison! Rafe finally declares that he KNOWS that he was wrong to put the war with Caleb ahead of Rafe's commitment to Alison! Rafe promises that, IF he had another chance, he WOULD make his commitment to Alison his FIRST priority! The Mystery Voice warns Rafe that NONE of Rafe's good intentions can EVER change Rafe's fate! The Mystery Voice told Rafe: "You have picked your path! Now it is time to see where it takes you! For reasons that will soon become clear, I have decided to set you free! It is time to meet your future!" Rafe is surprised when he is suddenly whisked back to the bedroom of the Loft he shares with Alison. Rafe is disappointed that he can NOT find Alison at the Loft, but decides to sit down and wait for Alison to return!

At the Old Barn, Caleb sadly remembers Livvie switching Caleb's Power Ring for the fake ring! Alison follows Caleb outside and informs Caleb that Alison KNOWS that Caleb has the fake ring on his finger. Caleb told Alison that it is NONE of her business, but, when Alison demands to know WHERE the real ring is, Alison finally guesses that LIVVIE has Caleb's power ring! Alison continues to beg Caleb to help her rescue Rafe, but Caleb sadly points out that he has been betrayed by the women in his life: the woman he loves and the woman who has proclaimed herself to be his friend. Alison immediately guesses that Caleb is referring to Livvie and implores Caleb to see how the war between Rafe and Caleb is destroying everything in BOTH of their lives that is the most important to them! Alison begs Caleb to go to Livvie and get the ring back and use the ring to rescue Rafe, but Caleb refuses! Alison then told Caleb that she KNOWS that, even without the ring, Caleb has OTHER powers and KNOWS dark secrets! Alison begs Caleb to use his OTHER powers to help free Rafe from the curse. But Caleb insists that Rafe's fate is out of Caleb's hands! When Alison tearfully wonders HOW she will be able to live without Rafe, Caleb consoles Alison. Then Caleb suddenly declares that he has felt a shift in the forces, and believes that Rafe has returned to the mortal world! Alison rushes in to Caleb's arms and thanks him for using his power to rescue Rafe. But Caleb insists that he had nothing to do with Rafe's return.

At the same time, Livvie sits in Caleb's apartment, with her romantic feast spread out on the table beside her, and wishes on the ring: "I wish for this to be the most romantic evening Caleb has ever known. I wish for Caleb to feel the kind of passion he has only dreamed of! I want this to be a night of intense love that Caleb will never forget. And I want him to ALWAYS know that I am the one who made it happen! And, out of this intense passion, I will get my greatest wish of all ~ at the end of the night, I wish..." As Livvie wishes on the ring, Caleb and Alison begin to kiss and soon hit the hay!